Show people what they can do, help them do it too, then see your service improve

Image by StartupStockPhotos from Pixabay

by Sam Milsom, Programme Development Manager at Open Data Manchester

Citizens’ Advice Manchester (CAM) is one of 280 independent charities under the Citizens’ Advice banner.

It offers free information and confidential advice on many aspects of life, including money, renting, benefits and legal support. The public can get advice over the phone, through online chatbots, and on messaging apps such as WhatsApp and Facebook Messenger. It also offers video calls, as well as in-person meetings (in ‘normal times’). 

CAM helps 60,000 to 70,000 people across the city of Manchester and the wider Greater Manchester city region every year thanks to its 150-strong team, made up of both paid staff and volunteers. 

Stuart Pearson, the Chief Digital Officer, has been working at CAM for 17 years. He describes himself as being “responsible for tech and everything that falls under that”. Even though Stuart has an understanding of data, he does not have a ‘traditional’ data-analysis background. 

He explains:

“One of the challenges that is probably replicated across the voluntary or social sector, particularly around data and for small and medium charities, is we often don’t have the luxury of having our own dedicated data analyst or data scientist. And so it often falls under somebody else’s responsibilities.”

Gathering data to report to funders or trustees, for example, used to fall to Stuart. He was the one who understood how to get the data out of the Customer Relationship Management (CRM) system and knew how to generate reports – and that role stuck with him – even though, like many who work in the sector, he had many other responsibilities.

CAM’s Contact Centre Team, whose main role is to help people with issues over the phone, sits on a very rich dataset. They take about 48,000 calls per year, recording information such as ‘purpose of call’, ‘help provided’ and ‘call length’, along with some very granular data on things like demographics and information about the particular issues people are experiencing. The team also collects direct feedback about the service people received, which is also extremely valuable. 

Stuart understood that this information could be put to more use, not just for delivering reports to funders – but to help improve their service delivery, and for campaigning and lobbying activities – another key area of activity for the charity.

“We’d not really used this data to ask what it was telling us about our clients. What were they telling us about their needs and how we could better help them? So that was the joint ambition – I wanted people to be more interested in data in our organisation and I wanted us as an organisation to deliver better services, by understanding the data better.”

In order to do this, Stuart completed a data maturity assessment, which helped get a better picture of where CAM was on its data journey. It also showed them the steps they needed to take to improve, specifically in areas such as data literacy and data-based decision-making. 

Stuart also went to Tech For Good events and spoke with organisations like Data Orchard, DataKind and Open Data Manchester – whose missions are to help organisations understand and make the most of their data. They all helped point him in the right direction and gave Stuart the confidence to be able to communicate what was needed with the right people. By including managers and trustees in this process, everyone was able to see the value of having an organisation-wide approach to data and to get a better understanding of how it might be used.

“The traditional attitude to data is very much ‘it’s something somebody else does’ and immediately we wanted to break that cycle, where people really needed to be interested in data.”

Working with a volunteer who had some data knowledge, Stuart was then able to pull together some datasets that showed the potential of the data the organisation has and explore what it’s telling them, and how they might use it to better deliver services. As a case study, he began by exploring the Contact Centre Team’s data, with the aim of making it available to the whole organisation, including the staff and volunteers who handle the calls.

Appreciating that “not all staff were going to feel comfortable using spreadsheets or pivot tables”, Stuart decided to use Google BigQuery with DataStudio on the front-end. This enabled him to create visual dashboards that people can easily filter to show information that is relevant to them. Suddenly this vast array of data was opened up to the team in a very accessible format and managers were able to make more-informed decisions within a quicker time, whilst also surfacing areas where their staff might require further training and support. These factors combined saw the team handle a 12% increase in calls during 2019, without the need for additional staff. 

An image of the CAM dashboard

It wasn’t all plain sailing, of course. With such detailed analyses of the Contact Centre Team’s work being opened up more widely, there was some resistance, due to a ‘big brother’ element, where staff and volunteers felt the data was being collected to keep watch on them. 

One of the ways CAM overcame this was to use the data in the creation of the team’s Key Performance Indicators (KPIs). Until then, KPI figures might have felt somewhat arbitrary, but they could now be based on information derived from the data. This meant things like call-length targets could be amended based on the actual length of calls that staff were taking. Because the whole team were able to take part in the discussions on how these new targets were set – and they’d seen an increase in the number of calls they were able to handle – this all fostered greater trust in the way the data could be used.

Since implementing these changes, there’s now a move to do similar things with other teams within the organisations. CAM has also created an internal Client Insights Panel, made up of trustees, members and volunteers from across the organisation, who meet on a bi-monthly basis to discuss what the data is telling them and to help foster a stronger culture of data.

Stuart says he no longer feels solely responsible for CAM’s data as he has been able to make a case to the trustees for the need to grow the digital team, with one person already put forward for data analytics training.

Everyone in the Contact Centre Team now has access to their data, whether that’s managers, trustees or volunteers. Decisions within the organisation are being made based on what the data is telling people, and staff and volunteers are now included in performance and delivery-based decisions. All of this ultimately means a better service for people in Greater Manchester who need advice.

This case study informs part of a report, ‘How the Social Sector is Overcoming Cultural Barriers Around Data Use to Transform the Services it Provides to the People Who Need Them Most’ by Open Data Manchester, in collaboration with Catalyst, to understand how the use of data is transforming the social sector. Find out more and download the full report here: