A community for people using data in the social sector
Data Collective pilot User Research Report
As part of the Data Collective pilot, there has been a dedicated user research strand. Over the last few months, the team behind the scenes of Data Collective have been researching what we should be aiming to achieve (while spinning up the Collective in parallel!). We have spoken with a diverse and representative group of people from across the social sector about their data needs but also how they may wish to work with others. Read more about the process in the methodology section of the full report below.
Lots of members of the Collective took part in this research. Thank you so much for your time! We are so grateful for your input.
Do these findings resonate with you? We’d love your thoughts on the findings and what they might mean for Data Collective. Does this sound like it’s what you need to make better use of data in your role? Email us and let us know what you think.
Introduction
“Work around data sharing is very valuable... facilitate networking; showcase progressive approaches and projects; [and] signpost to places that can help with specific issues [or] resources”
– Survey respondent from a large delivery charity
About the Data Collective pilot
Between November 2020 and April 2021, DataKind UK have been leading a consortium to pilot something called the ‘Data Collective’. The Data Collective is a community for those using data in the social sector. It’s intended to help charities and other civil society organisations to access, analyse and share data better.
The pilot is supported by Catalyst, as part of the Catalyst and The National Lottery Community Fund COVID-19 Digital Response fund. The pilot is an opportunity to test out the idea, trial some activities and learn if and how it could be sustained in the longer term.
The challenge to address
The initial challenges to prompt the conversation about a Data Collective stemmed from Covid-19. To be able to respond, particularly to protect the most vulnerable in our society (in the UK), there were particular things we needed to understand better. As highlighted by Catalyst in June 2020, these things included:
- The current and emerging needs of individuals and communities during the crisis;
- What services are being delivered to help meet those needs;
- Whether those services are effective;
- How the lockdown has financially impacted people and the organisations that serve them.
Part of the answer to these things lies in the disparate data held in multiple places and organisations across the social sector. The difficulty of joining these up, however, makes it hard to act on.
“If you make your data accessible and standardised, it’s much easier for people to use and for us to have a bigger impact together to support charities.”
– User research workshop participant from an infrastructure organisation in reference to data providers, such as the Charity Commission
The hypothesis
If we bring together a community of organisations from across the social sector with experience of working with data or a willingness to share data with each other and others, we could create the conditions – now and in the future – for better joint working that makes acting on these challenges easier.
About this user research
As part of the Data Collective pilot, there has been a dedicated user research strand. Its intention has been to speak with a diverse and representative group of people from across the social sector about their data needs but also how they may wish to work with others. This involved a number of interviews, workshops and a survey; all the details of which can be found in the methodology section. This was with a view to shaping the Data Collective’s activities, approach and structure in a way that’s informed by the people it intends to connect and support, both during the pilot and beyond. This page is a summary, the full report can be downloaded below.
The user research in two diagrams
The Data Collective logic model
As part of the user research process, we have mapped out a high level framework for what we think the Data Collective is trying to address and achieve, for whom and what it might it do to enable this. Some of these things have been tested through the pilot. The logic model serves two main purposes:- A simple, visual way to communicate what the Data Collective is and does;
- Provides a basis for measuring and evaluating its effectiveness in the longer term.
Personas and prerequisites
As part of the user research process, we have noticed four clear personas for people who have an appetite for being involved with the Data Collective, dependent on role and size of organisation. In addition to this, we have noticed that these personas are, although distinct, bound by two common traits:
- Their readiness or willingness to share data and experiences;
- One of the ways they all describe their roles is about ‘communicating data and insight’.
The user research in five key headlines
One: There is a need for a community of people collaborating and learning from each other about data sharing in the social sector
The hypothesis – that there is a need for a community of people collaborating and learning from each other about data sharing in the social sector – is correct and people within the sector gravitate towards the idea even if they are unclear as to its specific function.
Data work is ad-hoc across the sector, both within organisations and how it is joined up. People within the sector working on data are often isolated and unsupported within their organisations, which leads to a lack of investment – time, money and cultural – in changing the situation. Having a dedicated space to learn from other organisations is seen as a way to catalyse this change.
Two: The Data Collective needs to clarify how it’s different from other communities
To maximise the benefits of – and engagement with – the Data Collective, a particular effort must be made to set clear bounds for the Data Collective’s role and setting to distinguish it from existing communities of practice within the sector.
In particular, the user research uncovered that the Data Collective should not just be a place for data analysts/scientists to share expertise with each other, such as existing Datakind Slack communities, nor is it a place for the transfer of basic data skills to those working in charities. It is a place for focusing on data sharing between organisations in the sector and creating equal relationships to work together on this.
Three: The Data Collective is a facilitator, not a provider
Following on from the previous headline, people have expressed a preference for a community that promotes scheduled opportunities for learning through existing examples, conversation with other members and doing things together, rather than a provider of training or support. Some of the ways this can be facilitated is through the organising of content or conversations around themes or areas of interest, such as place, cause or type of organisation.
“We’re serving the same user group, we all know it’s a good idea, we could learn from each other… Let’s pool our data!”
– User research workshop participant
Four: One size doesn’t fit all and communicating the Data Collective’s role will be hard
Data, related expertise and the idea of sharing data evoke mixed emotions across the sector. People’s responses vary according to a whole host of variables, such as self-confidence, role, type of organisation, how they perceive ‘the sector’ and the sub-sector to which they belong. And these responses affect if or how they will engage with a community. Effort should be taken when communicating the Collective’s role and activities to choose language that is inclusive, and to focus on readiness to share, rather than technical expertise, as well as the desire to further social purpose.
Five: The Data Collective membership and activities should be varied and open, but there are prerequisites for getting involved to ensure focus
Throughout the conversations held as part of this research there has been a tension about who – organisations and individual roles types – should be in or out. In addition there has been a strong theme around how those in the sector on ‘the outside’ can still benefit from the Data Collective’s activities.
The focus of the Data Collective membership should be ‘data communicators’ within social sector organisations where the organisation is ready to share data and experiences. This is not necessarily the largest organisations or those with the highest data analysis capacity. Furthermore, the focus should always be on data sharing as this provides a focus and also a necessary barrier for those who aren’t quite ready yet.
What's next?
- Offer a tangible, clear offer to the sector for what this thing is! This research is one element of that. We’re currently using it to shape the next stage of the community
- Get funding to provide that offer. If you’re an interested funder or know of someone you think we should speak to, please get in touch!
- Keep learning from you and what you need. We’d love to hear your thoughts.
- Grow! The more of us there are, the better our community will be. If you know someone who should consider joining, here’s the link to share with them:
