by Sam Milsom, Programme Development Manager at Open Data Manchester
Lewisham Local is a small charity with seven members of staff that operates in south east London. It connects individuals, organisations and businesses to encourage local giving and share their skills, expertise and knowledge for the benefit of the local community.
Before the pandemic, Simone Riddle managed the organisation’s time bank, a skills exchange that was particularly focussed on reducing loneliness and isolation. She also manages the volunteer-led project FoodCycle Lewisham, which provides a hot meal cooked with surplus food to those who need it. Simone’s background is in participatory action research – seeking transformative change through taking action, research and reflection. She says, “I’ve not worked with numbers so much up until recently in this role”.
When the pandemic started, Lewisham Local came together with other local partners including Lewisham Council to organise a community-coordinated response to the effects of COVID-19. Over the past year they have been developing a network of community projects encouraging multiple groups to work together to support Lewisham’s diverse communities.
With an increase in usage of food banks at the start of the pandemic, some food projects saw increases of around 50 to 180 families. The local council wanted to have access to data such as this along with more granular information in order to better understand demand for emergency food provision to monitor levels of food insecurity. Part of Simone’s role was to assist and coordinate the collection and sharing of this data.
However, most food banks simply didn’t have the time or resources to collect such information. And even for those who were able to, there was an issue of trust, something which Simone understands implicitly and was well positioned to help with.
There are over 40 food projects in Lewisham, and being able to collect and share this data would not only be vital for monitoring levels of food security but also to help secure financial support and resource sharing.
However, they all operate independently with different levels of data collection and quality, and some were less prepared to share than others. Where some saw the benefit of sharing such data, others were resistant, seeing issues of privacy or mistrust in the potential uses of the data.
For Simone, building trust and strong relationships is a priority. She facilitated weekly meetings as a space for groups to connect, to share updates and changes in need, and problem-solve together. She began the process by approaching six of the larger food projects, who were in a better position to share their data. They completed a form to produce weekly reports that could be distributed to the council, communicate needs between projects and which would ultimately help to secure further financial assistance.
To make data collection as simple as possible, Simone created a Salesforce form, which could then be used to generate the weekly reports to share with the council and the network. It was designed to collect only the most vital data and to make data collection as easy as possible.
“What we’re hearing from those collecting the data is ‘the less bureaucracy, the fewer questions people are being asked, the better’. They appreciate it. It builds trust, it helps break down barriers. On the other side, we know that there’s been massive disparities in the people affected, and through COVID-19 and other inequalities. So we’re trying to build up a picture without asking too much, and making sure the data is being used.”
The use of the Salesforce form made it easy to collect and share data, but for already time-strapped projects, simply remembering to fill it out on time can be difficult. So Simone used email and communication tools like Whatsapp to send weekly reminders. Where necessary, she followed up with some projects individually. Whilst this could be quite work-intensive, over time this system of data collection, communication and sharing has become more embedded.
Simone was also able to make use of some free data literacy training, which provided the food projects with an introduction to data, and explored how to map their organisations’ data so they could spot food deserts and focus resources. It also provided some assistance in accessing other datasets, such as the Indices of Deprivation, which could help them understand their communities.
These sessions not only helped to build confidence in using data, but also fostsered trust in what Simone was trying to achieve between the food projects and the council. To illustrate this, Simone tells me that one food project, who prefer to operate on a more Mutual Aid model, attended the data literacy training, and were immediately able to see the benefit of collecting and sharing data with the council.
As a result of the food projects collaborating and sharing data in this way, Simone was able to put together a report to highlight levels and areas of need and the response of local food groups. The recommendations from which formed a project proposal which was awarded £35,964 from the Wave 3 London Community Response Fund to continue to develop the food network and the surplus food hub.
With data sharing embedded, Lewisham Local is now expanding the reporting and data sharing with more groups — but Simone needed to be able to show the benefit of doing so first, in order to build the trust within the food projects.
Many food projects operate in isolation – usually because of time and resources, but also due to matters of privacy and trust. Lewisham Local was able to bring together groups and get them to collaborate successfully by making it easy for them to collect and share information, giving access to data literacy training, and demonstrating the positive impact of doing so.
The weekly reports have helped to make what they all do more visible, so they can share resources more easily, support each other and obtain funding. All of this helped build trust in data and in the sharing of data, between the projects and the council, but also between the projects themselves.
“It shows the impact. You’re more visible, because you’re sharing that information. Partners know who you are. You’re contributing to showing your impact, as well as helping to demonstrate need. And then over time, you see some of the other projects mentioning what needs they have. That’s been the small incentive as we go along. Like, this week one project needed more nappies, and so I’ll try and get that in the newsletter to go out. That’s what I feel has been the buy-in.”
This case study informs part of a report, ‘How the Social Sector is Overcoming Cultural Barriers Around Data Use to Transform the Services it Provides to the People Who Need Them Most’ by Open Data Manchester, in collaboration with Catalyst, to understand how the use of data is transforming the social sector. Find out more and download the full report here:
