Why do we know so little about the charity sector’s data?

Image by Pexels from Pixabay

By Anouskha Kenley, Research and Policy Director at Pro Bono Economics.

If you “measure what you treasure”, does X mark the spot where charities are buried?

They say you should measure what matters. And as a nation, we’re pretty good at that; blessed with one of the most respected and forward-thinking statistical offices in the world. That strength has come to the fore during the pandemic, with the Office for National Statistics working overtime to generate new data at pace in order to keep researchers and policymakers up to date with the latest health, social, and economic developments associated with the Covid-19 crisis.

Consider the fortnightly business insights data for example. The latest release tells us that in mid-April, 22% of businesses were temporarily closed, 36% had a lower turnover than they would normally expect, and 30% had less than four months’ worth of reserves in the bank. Some industries were faring worse than others at this time: 48% of the accommodation and food services sector had paused trading, compared to only 6% of the manufacturing sector.

How does this all compare to what charities currently face? The short answer is: we don’t know. This sort of detailed, timely data about the charity sector isn’t available. And this has been a big problem over the past year, making it much harder for the government to work out exactly how much support charities needed, and where that need is greatest.

Why do we know so little about the state of the charity sector, particularly compared to the private sector?

Charities (and other social sector organisations, like co-operatives and CICs) are included in plenty of official government data. This includes information like VAT and PAYE records, business demography data, and the Labour Force Survey. This is the data that tells us how different industries are faring in bad times and in good, and helps us understand the fluctuations in size and shape that occur in different sectors. But picking charities out of those data sets is either difficult, or impossible. Most of this data is organised by Standard Industrial Classification (SIC) codes. Charities can sit in a range of industrial sectors, so with no easy way to identify them, this classification doesn’t help us understand them as a whole.

This is frustrating because this data is being collected, and much of it is completely up to date. If we could identify charities in some of these data sets, we’d know much more about how the sector has been faring through Covid-19 (and much more besides).

There are other public data sources that also contain lots of information about charities. The Care Quality Commission, for example, regulates a lot of registered charities and social sector organisations. But with no straightforward way to identify charities in these data sets – and no system of tagging to link data sitting in different places – we can’t build up the detailed picture of who’s doing what, where, and how they’re doing it, that we’d like to.

Instead, we primarily depend on the annual accounts submitted to charity regulators. This is a rich information source, though you need some decent technical skills to access much of it. And more importantly, while this data is used to build NCVO’s excellent (and much more accessible) UK Civil Society Almanac, it necessarily runs at a 2-3 year lag. So this data doesn’t say much about the state of the charity sector today, or even last year.

All this means that while we have comprehensive and timely data about the health of the private sector, everything we know about how charities at the moment depends on organisations, like Pro Bono Economics, trying to fill the gaps.

Getting a better handle on data about the health of the charity sector is no easy task – but it is possible. This won’t be cost-free for the Government, so can we persuade them that it’s a worthwhile investment? That’s one task of the Law Family Commission on Civil Society, where Pro Bono Economics are starting to explore the implications of these charity sector data gaps. After all, it matters what we measure.